TSP: history is context
26–21Hermes NCAAF Score · fall 2026
+4.21u · 3.83% ROI
All logged: 63–45–1, +14.23u, 7.89% ROI. Older versions drive much of that profit: scores 40+ are only 26–24–1, +0.23u, ~0.2% ROI.
The 80–89 bucket is 4–2, +7.32u; 60–69 is 6–7, −3.66u. Tiny samples do not calibrate today’s score into a win probability.
Consensus: 9–7 source rows, 8–6 distinct picks. Compass NCAAF: 24–25, −2.03u, −13.6% ROI; parlay legs are not straight-bet endorsements.
Claude / Grok: what changed
- SC downgrade accepted. Claude sought −125; Grok sought about −121. Neither became our new automatic entry gate.
- A&M retained. Claude’s attribution challenge used Fallica’s different FOX article; his original X card confirms −14. Grok’s Arkansas +14 objection remains an opinion; Powers’ A&M downgrade is not a published Arkansas bet.
- New watches, stricter limits. Claude’s Navy/UCF unders remain below ND–UNC. Grok helped surface Powers’ UK–SC over and updated Temple/ASU limits; Temple +5.5 stays excluded.
- Corrections accepted. Both converged on the fall Score ledger after excluding the In-Play-only Texas winner. Grok corrected Miami price direction and Radar arithmetic. Assistant agreement adds no independent evidence.
Additional audit notes & lower-priority peer opinions
Calendar 2026 Hermes NCAAF is 28–23, +4.11u, including January games; it is a different window from fall. SRI441 public rows are 8–7 overall and 6–3 NCAAF. The advertised 13–8 scope and a note changing 11–7 to 11–6 remain unresolved. Do not invent missing wins.
Book Need/Radar frozen bases and later additions have different scopes. Recent NCAAF Radar 19–14 is 57.6%. Some readings require a Notes-field fallback. Period mismatches, incomplete MLB angle/grade comparisons and the Compass NHL date anomaly remain flagged, without silently regrading. Cross-feed Score/In-Play labels and two different totals are not automatically errors.
Grok’s Bowling Green +12/+12.5, BYU −6, Florida −5.5, USC −9 and Miami–Clemson under 48 remain peer opinions, alongside Arkansas +14. McComb’s final status matters for Bowling Green; USC’s Powers comment had no price. No verified priced Rufus CFB wager was recovered. The absence of a Compass parlay from a historical CSV did not disprove the separately observed live card.
Fallica’s 10–11 notation was mixed NFL/CFB, not CFB-only. Northwestern was already final Friday and stays excluded. Line movement, public splits, source counts and four-bet losing buckets do not prove sharp action, EV or a profitable fade rule.